Ten games are scheduled on September 14, and the tightest race in baseball opens the evening: Chicago and Cleveland are separated by half a game at the top of the AL Central and meet at Progressive Field. Elsewhere, Tarik Skubal takes the largest statistical separation between any two probable starters into Cincinnati, the Cubs put the majors' most productive offense on the field at Wrigley against an Atlanta club leading the NL East, and San Diego carries a seven-game winning streak into Coors Field. Several rotations are also handing the ball to pitchers with very little season workload behind them, including probable starters with one, four and six career starts on the year. All starters listed below were probable when the day's data was collected.
Read moreShow less
A half-game separates the White Sox and Guardians in Cleveland
Chicago is 76-73 and holds first place in the AL Central; Cleveland is 76-74 and occupies the third AL Wild Card position. The standings say these teams are indistinguishable, but their current form does not. The White Sox have lost seven of ten, while the Guardians have won six of ten and took a series-opening win into this meeting. Chicago has won six of the ten games between them.
The probable starters create a genuine puzzle. Sean Newcomb owns the better ERA at 2.77, the better FIP at 2.88 and a 0.21 HR/9 that no other starter on the slate approaches, yet he has made only five starts and has not recorded a quality start in any of them. Gavin Williams has been the conventional workhorse, with 29 starts, 169 innings and a 12.1 K/9 that ranks fifth among the 235 qualified starters in the supplied pool.
The offensive comparison tilts toward Chicago, which ranks fourth in MLB at 4.66 runs per game against Cleveland's 17th-ranked 4.10. Both bullpens rank inside the top eight in ERA, with Cleveland's relievers missing considerably more bats at 10.3 K/9.
Skubal takes the day's widest pitching gap into Great American Ball Park
No probable matchup on the schedule shows more separation than this one. Skubal's FIP advantage over Nick Lodolo is 3.05, and the supporting numbers run the same direction: a 2.84 ERA against 5.12, a 0.97 WHIP that ranks 10th in the starter pool against a 1.53 that ranks 205th, and 1.6 walks per nine against 3.8. Skubal has delivered quality starts in 61% of his outings; Lodolo in 22%.
Los Angeles arrives at 90-59 and leading the NL West, having won eight of ten despite dropping its last two. The Dodgers rank second in MLB in runs per game, on-base percentage, slugging and OPS, and they have been better on the road (43-31) than Cincinnati has been at home (36-38). They also swept the only three games these teams have played this season.
Cincinnati's one real asset in this matchup is power. The Reds rank third in MLB with 199 home runs, which offers a path to runs that does not require stringing hits together against a pitcher who rarely allows them. Their bullpen, 25th in ERA at 4.84 and 25th in WHIP, is a harder problem. The complete Dodgers–Reds preview breaks down the pitching comparison in more detail.
Chicago's league-leading offense meets two starters with command problems
The Cubs lead MLB in runs per game (5.33), on-base percentage (.339), slugging (.430), OPS (.769) and home runs (207), and they have been substantially better at Wrigley Field (43-32) than away from it. They also hold the top NL Wild Card position by a game and a half. Atlanta leads the NL East at 88-62 and has won 13 of its last 20, the best 20-game stretch among the teams playing on this schedule.
Neither probable starter has pitched like a stopper. David Peterson's 5.28 ERA ranks 184th in the pool and his 1.58 WHIP ranks 216th, though his 4.15 FIP suggests the run prevention has been worse than the underlying performance. Reynaldo López has the lower ERA at 4.13, but his FIP is the higher of the two at 4.41, and he has produced a quality start in just 8% of his 12 outings.
Where Atlanta separates itself is in relief. The Braves' bullpen ranks third in MLB in ERA at 3.41 and second in WHIP at 1.20, against Chicago's 11th-ranked unit, which also allows 1.39 home runs per nine at a park where that number matters. Our full Braves–Cubs preview digs further into the starting matchup and bullpen contrast.
San Diego's seven-game winning streak reaches Coors Field
Few teams on this schedule are playing better than the Padres, who have won seven straight and eight of ten while holding the third NL Wild Card spot. Colorado has gone the other way entirely, losing seven in a row and 15 of its last 20, with a 30-41 home record. San Diego has won eight of the nine meetings between them.
The oddity here is that Colorado, at 55-94, ranks third in MLB in runs per game (4.67), OPS (.737) and slugging (.415). The Rockies can hit; almost nothing else has held up, and their bullpen ranks 27th in both ERA (4.97) and WHIP (1.49).
Casey Mize holds a clear edge over Tomoyuki Sugano in ERA (3.70 to 5.30), FIP (3.61 to 5.41) and WHIP (1.11 to 1.34), and the gap in strikeout rate is stark: Sugano's 5.5 K/9 ranks 227th among 235 qualified starters, and his 1.90 HR/9 is the highest figure any probable starter carries into this slate. Both pitchers throw strikes, sharing an identical 2.2 BB/9. See the full Padres–Rockies preview for a closer look at how the starters match up.
Other games to follow
Detroit at Toronto — an ERA and a FIP that disagree sharply. Troy Melton's 2.42 ERA ranks ninth in the starter pool, but his 4.06 FIP is the less favorable of the two probables; José Soriano's 3.48 ERA comes with a 3.93 FIP. Detroit has won four straight and Toronto two, and the Blue Jays sit one game out of the fourth AL Wild Card position.
New York Yankees at Minnesota — the largest bullpen gap on the schedule. New York's relief corps ranks second in MLB in ERA (3.14) and third in WHIP (1.20); Minnesota's ranks 26th and 28th. Dean Kremer's 2.01 HR/9 is the highest among probable starters, and the Twins have lost 13 of their last 20. Minnesota did take two of three in the season series.
Baltimore at New York Mets — a first meeting with a first-time starter. Jonah Tong has one start and 15 innings on his season ledger, too little to read in either direction, while Brandon Young brings 25 starts and a 48% quality-start rate, if a 4.51 FIP that runs well above his 3.71 ERA. The Mets have won seven of ten; Baltimore has lost seven of ten.
San Francisco at St. Louis — the Giants have swept the series so far. San Francisco is 26-49 on the road and 62-88 overall, yet it has won all three meetings with St. Louis. Landen Roupp holds narrow edges in ERA, FIP and WHIP over Quinn Mathews, whose 30.2 innings across six starts make his line difficult to evaluate.
Seattle at Los Angeles Angels — Detmers has the day's second-largest FIP edge. Reid Detmers pairs a 3.04 FIP with a 1.04 WHIP and 10.2 K/9, a 2.16 FIP advantage over Kade Anderson, who has thrown 21 innings across four starts. The offenses rank 18th and 19th in runs per game, so scoring may be scarce regardless.
Miami at Arizona — Alcantara's 200 innings against a three-inning sample. Sandy Alcantara leads all probable starters with 200 innings and a 68% quality-start rate. Corbin Burnes has made one start covering three innings, and no meaningful rate statistics can be drawn from it. Arizona holds the fourth NL Wild Card spot and is 42-33 at home; Miami has won all three previous meetings.
What stands out on September 14
The AL Central is the only division on this schedule where the two teams involved are separated by less than a game, and it is being decided by clubs moving in opposite directions. The NL Wild Card picture is more crowded: Chicago holds the top spot by a game and a half, San Diego occupies the third position while riding the longest active winning streak on the slate, Arizona sits 2.5 games back, and Miami trails by 7.5.
The other thread running through the day is uncertainty at the top of rotations. Four probable starters — Tong, Burnes, Anderson and Mathews — have combined for a fraction of a normal season's workload, and a fifth, Newcomb, carries excellent ratios across only five starts. That leaves the most reliable pitching comparisons concentrated in a few games: Skubal in Cincinnati, Detmers in Anaheim, and Mize at the one ballpark where a strikeout rate as low as Sugano's is hardest to survive.
