Season Schedule
OffSTRegASGRegPostWSOff
Road to Playoffs
Open board →
Playoff odds, bubble teams & races — 30 clubs
5in the bubble
Payton Tolle
#
70
Team
BOS · P
Debut
2025 · 2 MLB seasons

Payton Tolle

Age 23
Contract Value $678,749/yr
Size 6' 6" · 250
Throws LHP
Bats Left
From Stillwater, OK
5-6 W-L
3.31
ERA
1.10
WHIP
9.6
K/9
2.6
BB/9
89.2
Innings
16
Starts
Payton Tolle season snapshot
Season stats
ERA
3.31
WHIP
1.10
K/9
9.6
BB/9
2.6
HR/9
0.90
IP
89.2
GS
16
W-L
5-6
◆ Pitcher snapshot

Payton Tolle, a starter for the Boston Red Sox, has put together a season that blends useful swing-and-miss ability with generally steady run prevention. The L-hander enters this stretch with a 5-6 record across 16 starts and 89.2, pairing a 3.31 ERA with a 1.10 WHIP while showing the traits of a pitcher who can help stabilize a rotation.

His profile is built around a solid strikeout foundation and workable control, reflected in a 9.64 K/9 and 2.61 BB/9. When he is locating well, he can get ahead, limit traffic, and force hitters into less comfortable at-bats. The overall shape of his season suggests a pitcher whose baseline is dependable, though occasional lapses in command or execution can still create shorter outings than fantasy managers or the club would prefer.

Recent form:

Recent starts
  • 07/205.2 IP · 4 ER · 9 K
  • 07/123.2 IP · 1 ER · 7 K
  • 07/076.0 IP · 0 ER · 6 K
  • 07/013.0 IP · 6 ER · 5 K
  • 06/267.0 IP · 0 ER · 7 K

Since he last pitched, the results have pointed to a down trend overall, even if the game log still shows some volatility from start to start. Payton Tolle has pitched well enough in recent outings to remain relevant in most formats, especially when the matchup gives him room to lean on his strikeout ability and avoid extended innings.

Looking ahead, the key question is how consistently he can maintain efficiency deep into games while keeping free passes in check. If the command holds, his current ratios are supportable and there is room for more wins than the 5 and 6 totals currently show.

Payton Tolle ERA trend
Last 6
Earned runs per start
Avg 2.3 ER / start
⚡ Alternating good/bad starts — volatile pattern.

Payton Tolle game log

2026 season
DateOpponentIPHERKBBERA
Jul 20Baltimore Orioles5.284916.92
Jul 12New York Mets3.231712.81
Jul 7Chicago White Sox620610.00
Jul 1Washington Nationals3765318.00
Jun 26New York Yankees710720.00
Jun 21Seattle Mariners663224.50
Jun 16Toronto Blue Jays543625.40
Jun 9Tampa Bay Rays694316.00
Jun 3Baltimore Orioles670520.00
May 28Atlanta Braves4.252724.29
May 22Minnesota Twins643924.50
May 16Atlanta Braves842312.25
May 10Tampa Bay Rays561401.80
May 4Detroit Tigers710810.00
Apr 28Toronto Blue Jays4.233446.43
Apr 23New York Yankees6311111.50

Payton Tolle season splits

Home / away / vs L-R · 2026
Away ERA
ERA3.41
vs Left AVG
AVG0.230
vs Right AVG
AVG0.209
Home ERA
ERA3.38
Payton Tolle monthly splits
ERA · IP · K · BB · WHIP per month
MonthGSERAIPKBBWHIP
Apr23.3810.21551.03
May52.3530.23160.85
Jun53.0030.02391.20
Jul45.4018.12761.42
Pitch arsenal
Usage and average velocity · 2026
FFFour-seam FB
47.9%96.0 mph
SISinker
22.3%95.0 mph
FCCutter
18.8%88.3 mph
CUCurveball
7.9%82.5 mph
CHChangeup
3.2%88.5 mph

Performance vs teams

2026 starts · sorted by ERA

Hot / Cold zones

Opponent results by strike zone area

AVG by zone

  • Zone 01: .167
  • Zone 02: .133
  • Zone 03: .227
  • Zone 04: .286
  • Zone 05: .159
  • Zone 06: .222
  • Zone 07: .278
  • Zone 08: .238
  • Zone 09: .318
  • Zone 11: .091
  • Zone 12: .258
  • Zone 13: .154
  • Zone 14: .429

OPS by zone

  • Zone 01: .625
  • Zone 02: .367
  • Zone 03: .500
  • Zone 04: .778
  • Zone 05: .386
  • Zone 06: .741
  • Zone 07: .667
  • Zone 08: .476
  • Zone 09: .909
  • Zone 11: .333
  • Zone 12: .700
  • Zone 13: .559
  • Zone 14: 1.150

SLG by zone

  • Zone 01: .458
  • Zone 02: .233
  • Zone 03: .273
  • Zone 04: .514
  • Zone 05: .227
  • Zone 06: .519
  • Zone 07: .389
  • Zone 08: .238
  • Zone 09: .591
  • Zone 11: .091
  • Zone 12: .355
  • Zone 13: .269
  • Zone 14: .786

OBP by zone

  • Zone 01: .167
  • Zone 02: .133
  • Zone 03: .250
  • Zone 04: .278
  • Zone 05: .159
  • Zone 06: .222
  • Zone 07: .278
  • Zone 08: .238
  • Zone 09: .318
  • Zone 11: .259
  • Zone 12: .425
  • Zone 13: .353
  • Zone 14: .600

earnedRunAverage by zone

  • Zone 01: -
  • Zone 02: -
  • Zone 03: -
  • Zone 04: -
  • Zone 05: -
  • Zone 06: -
  • Zone 07: -
  • Zone 08: -
  • Zone 09: -
  • Zone 11: -
  • Zone 12: -
  • Zone 13: -
  • Zone 14: -

numberOfStrikes by zone

  • Zone 01: 32.00
  • Zone 02: 93.00
  • Zone 03: 69.00
  • Zone 04: 65.00
  • Zone 05: 74.00
  • Zone 06: 67.00
  • Zone 07: 47.00
  • Zone 08: 39.00
  • Zone 09: 35.00
  • Zone 11: 40.00
  • Zone 12: 55.00
  • Zone 13: 59.00
  • Zone 14: 19.00

numberOfPitches by zone

  • Zone 01: 55.00
  • Zone 02: 113.00
  • Zone 03: 89.00
  • Zone 04: 92.00
  • Zone 05: 111.00
  • Zone 06: 88.00
  • Zone 07: 67.00
  • Zone 08: 61.00
  • Zone 09: 55.00
  • Zone 11: 131.00
  • Zone 12: 215.00
  • Zone 13: 179.00
  • Zone 14: 104.00
0.4000.3000.200
.154.091.258.429.167.133.227.286.159.222.278.238.318
0.4000.3000.200

Last 10 matchups

More MLB pitcher profiles

Similar starters by ERA and workload — refreshed on each visit.