Final lineupsLineups only · full preview is a separate page

St. Louis Cardinals vs Milwaukee Brewers Starting Lineups — September 25, 2026

Batting orders, positions, season stats, splits against the opposing starter's hand and batter-versus-pitcher history with sample size for both clubs.

7:40 PM ET · American Family FieldFinal lineups locked · Sep 25, 5:40 PM ETStats updated Oct 29, 6:02 AM ET
STL
77–85 · 4th NL Central
Official
HandLHP
L / R bats2 L / 6 R / 1 S
OPS vs hand.697 vs LHP
MIL
103–59 · 1st NL Central
Official
HandRHP
L / R bats6 L / 2 R / 1 S
OPS vs hand.759 vs RHP

Lineup strength vs today's starter

Weighted by batting-order spot. Season rates are regressed toward league average before they enter the model.

Updated Sep 25, 5:40 PM ET
STLSTL
.694
−39 ptsOPS edge
MILMIL
.733

Slight edge: MIL

Power
Season HR
88vs105
Discipline
Adj. OBP
.317vs.334
Top of order
Slots 1–4
.746vs.792
Bottom of order
Slots 7–9
.619vs.656

STL wins 1 of 9 batting-order slots · MIL wins 8

STLSlotMIL
JJ Wetherholt.716
1
.764Garrett Mitchell
Iván Herrera.736
2
.795Brice Turang
Jordan Walker.787
3
.755William Contreras
Leo Bernal.749
4
.859Jake Bauers
José Fermín.687
5
.699Christian Yelich
Thomas Saggese.686
6
.722Joey Ortiz
Masyn Winn.643
7
.670Luis Lara
Pedro Pagés.625
8
.642Sal Frelick
Victor Scott II.589
9
.654David Hamilton

7 of 9 St. Louis Cardinals hitters have the platoon advantage vs Robert Gasser (7 of 9 for Milwaukee Brewers)

St. Louis Cardinals
  • Platoon advantage in 7 of 9 spots
  • Bottom third drops off sharply
Milwaukee Brewers
  • Strong top of the order
  • Platoon advantage in 7 of 9 spots
  • Bottom third drops off sharply

St. Louis Cardinals batting order

Official lineupvs LHP Robert Gasser
#HitterPosH-ScoreAVGOBPOPSHRPAOPS vs HandBvP
1JJ WetherholtL2B55.242.339.70417619.664211 PA0-for-4 · 4 PAVery small sample
1JJ Wetherholt 2B · L.242/.339/.704·17 HRvs hand.664 · 211 PA · 0-for-4 · 4 PA · Very small55H-Score
2Iván HerreraRDH60.241.353.73519717.7872-for-4 · 4 PAVery small sample
2Iván Herrera DH · R.241/.353/.735·19 HRvs hand.787 · 2-for-4 · 4 PA · Very small60H-Score
3Jordan WalkerRRF73.269.327.79329667.863175 PA0-for-1 · 1 PAVery small sample
3Jordan Walker RF · R.269/.327/.793·29 HRvs hand.863 · 175 PA · 0-for-1 · 1 PA · Very small73H-Score
4Leo BernalSC60.284.333.8075102.64717 PA · Limited historyNo MLB historyNo MLB history
4Leo Bernal C · S.284/.333/.807·5 HRvs hand.647 · 17 PA · No MLB history · No MLB60H-Score
5José FermínRLF41.248.309.6646370.7470-for-3 · 3 PAVery small sample
5José Fermín LF · R.248/.309/.664·6 HRvs hand.747 · 0-for-3 · 3 PA · Very small41H-Score
6Thomas SaggeseRSS44.235.294.6464180.9690-for-2 · 2 PAVery small sample
6Thomas Saggese SS · R.235/.294/.646·4 HRvs hand.969 · 0-for-2 · 2 PA · Very small44H-Score
7Masyn WinnRSS42.232.308.6255532.7451-for-2 · 2 PAVery small sample
7Masyn Winn SS · R.232/.308/.625·5 HRvs hand.745 · 1-for-2 · 2 PA · Very small42H-Score
8Pedro PagésRC26.217.275.5874211.490No MLB historyNo MLB history
8Pedro Pagés C · R.217/.275/.587·4 HRvs hand.490 · No MLB history · No MLB26H-Score
9Victor Scott IILCF25.193.270.5232195.61164 PANo MLB historyNo MLB history
9Victor Scott II CF · L.193/.270/.523·2 HRvs hand.611 · 64 PA · No MLB history · No MLB25H-Score

Milwaukee Brewers batting order

Official lineupvs RHP Michael McGreevy
#HitterPosH-ScoreAVGOBPOPSHRPAOPS vs HandBvP
1Garrett MitchellLCF68.262.354.77011531.802402 PA2-for-5 · 5 PASmall sample
1Garrett Mitchell CF · L.262/.354/.770·11 HRvs hand.802 · 402 PA · 2-for-5 · 5 PA · Small68H-Score
2Brice TurangL2B73.268.366.81621680.901478 PA0-for-2 · 2 PAVery small sample
2Brice Turang 2B · L.268/.366/.816·21 HRvs hand.901 · 478 PA · 0-for-2 · 2 PA · Very small73H-Score
3William ContrerasRC71.270.341.75818640.757457 PA1-for-6 · 6 PASmall sample
3William Contreras C · R.270/.341/.758·18 HRvs hand.757 · 457 PA · 1-for-6 · 6 PA · Small71H-Score
4Jake BauersL1B81.266.389.87326578.863418 PA2-for-4 · 4 PAVery small sample
4Jake Bauers 1B · L.266/.389/.873·26 HRvs hand.863 · 418 PA · 2-for-4 · 4 PA · Very small81H-Score
5Christian YelichLDH55.235.315.69312500.722370 PA3-for-6 · 6 PASmall sample
5Christian Yelich DH · L.235/.315/.693·12 HRvs hand.722 · 370 PA · 3-for-6 · 6 PA · Small55H-Score
6Joey OrtizRSS55.270.328.7309415.768265 PA0-for-2 · 2 PAVery small sample
6Joey Ortiz SS · R.270/.328/.730·9 HRvs hand.768 · 265 PA · 0-for-2 · 2 PA · Very small55H-Score
7Luis LaraSRF40.246.311.6361212.662140 PA1-for-3 · 3 PAVery small sample
7Luis Lara RF · S.246/.311/.636·1 HRvs hand.662 · 140 PA · 1-for-3 · 3 PA · Very small40H-Score
8Sal FrelickLRF38.230.295.6144384.640286 PA1-for-1 · 1 PAVery small sample
8Sal Frelick RF · L.230/.295/.614·4 HRvs hand.640 · 286 PA · 1-for-1 · 1 PA · Very small38H-Score
9David HamiltonL3B39.245.314.6504387.668306 PA0-for-2 · 2 PAVery small sample
9David Hamilton 3B · L.245/.314/.650·4 HRvs hand.668 · 306 PA · 0-for-2 · 2 PA · Very small39H-Score