Final lineupsLineups only · full preview is a separate page

St. Louis Cardinals vs Pittsburgh Pirates Starting Lineups — September 23, 2026

Batting orders, positions, season stats, splits against the opposing starter's hand and batter-versus-pitcher history with sample size for both clubs.

6:40 PM ET · PNC ParkFinal lineups locked · Sep 23, 4:40 PM ETStats updated Oct 29, 3:36 AM ET
STL
77–85 · 4th NL Central
Official
HandRHP
L / R bats4 L / 4 R / 1 S
OPS vs hand.688 vs RHP
PIT
82–80 · 3rd NL Central
Official
HandLHP
L / R bats2 L / 4 R / 3 S
OPS vs hand.701 vs LHP

Lineup strength vs today's starter

Weighted by batting-order spot. Season rates are regressed toward league average before they enter the model.

Updated Sep 23, 4:40 PM ET
STLSTL
.721
−28 ptsOPS edge
PITPIT
.749

Slight edge: PIT

Power
Season HR
120vs98
Discipline
Adj. OBP
.325vs.335
Top of order
Slots 1–4
.761vs.783
Bottom of order
Slots 7–9
.670vs.704

STL wins 3 of 9 batting-order slots · PIT wins 6

STLSlotPIT
JJ Wetherholt.711
1
.721Konnor Griffin
Iván Herrera.743
2
.826Rafael Flores Jr.
Alec Burleson.801
3
.781Bryan Reynolds
Jordan Walker.795
4
.806Brandon Lowe
Leo Bernal.786
5
.749Nick Gonzales
Nolan Gorman.620
6
.730Ronny Simon
José Fermín.686
7
.762Ryan O'Hearn
Nathan Church.679
8
.640Jared Triolo
Masyn Winn.644
9
.709Jake Mangum

5 of 9 St. Louis Cardinals hitters have the platoon advantage vs Lake Bachar (7 of 9 for Pittsburgh Pirates)

St. Louis Cardinals
  • Real power throughout the lineup
Pittsburgh Pirates
  • Strong top of the order
  • Platoon advantage in 7 of 9 spots

St. Louis Cardinals batting order

Official lineupvs RHP Lake Bachar
#HitterPosH-ScoreAVGOBPOPSHRPAOPS vs HandBvP
1JJ WetherholtL2B55.242.339.70417619.732375 PA1-for-1 · 1 PAVery small sample
1JJ Wetherholt 2B · L.242/.339/.704·17 HRvs hand.732 · 375 PA · 1-for-1 · 1 PA · Very small55H-Score
2Iván HerreraRDH60.241.353.73519717.6971-for-4 · 4 PAVery small sample
2Iván Herrera DH · R.241/.353/.735·19 HRvs hand.697 · 1-for-4 · 4 PA · Very small60H-Score
3Alec BurlesonL1B71.279.343.81626670.939435 PA1-for-1 · 1 PAVery small sample
3Alec Burleson 1B · L.279/.343/.816·26 HRvs hand.939 · 435 PA · 1-for-1 · 1 PA · Very small71H-Score
4Jordan WalkerRRF73.269.327.79329667.769492 PA1-for-1 · 1 PAVery small sample
4Jordan Walker RF · R.269/.327/.793·29 HRvs hand.769 · 492 PA · 1-for-1 · 1 PA · Very small73H-Score
5Leo BernalSC60.284.333.8075102.89935 PANo MLB historyNo MLB history
5Leo Bernal C · S.284/.333/.807·5 HRvs hand.899 · 35 PA · No MLB history · No MLB60H-Score
6Nolan GormanL3B40.184.272.5809302.598253 PANo MLB historyNo MLB history
6Nolan Gorman 3B · L.184/.272/.580·9 HRvs hand.598 · 253 PA · No MLB history · No MLB40H-Score
7José FermínRLF41.248.309.6646370.6050-for-1 · 1 PAVery small sample
7José Fermín LF · R.248/.309/.664·6 HRvs hand.605 · 0-for-1 · 1 PA · Very small41H-Score
8Nathan ChurchLCF41.247.290.65410470.671364 PA0-for-2 · 2 PAVery small sample
8Nathan Church CF · L.247/.290/.654·10 HRvs hand.671 · 364 PA · 0-for-2 · 2 PA · Very small41H-Score
9Masyn WinnRSS42.232.308.6255532.5942-for-3 · 3 PAVery small sample
9Masyn Winn SS · R.232/.308/.625·5 HRvs hand.594 · 2-for-3 · 3 PA · Very small42H-Score

Pittsburgh Pirates batting order

Official lineupvs LHP Matthew Liberatore
#HitterPosH-ScoreAVGOBPOPSHRPAOPS vs HandBvP
1Konnor GriffinRSS45.272.324.7286339.8220-for-3 · 3 PAVery small sample
1Konnor Griffin SS · R.272/.324/.728·6 HRvs hand.822 · 0-for-3 · 3 PA · Very small45H-Score
2Rafael Flores Jr.RC61.264.331.85811163.8090-for-1 · 1 PAVery small sample
2Rafael Flores Jr. C · R.264/.331/.858·11 HRvs hand.809 · 0-for-1 · 1 PA · Very small61H-Score
3Bryan ReynoldsSLF69.261.365.78917699.8243-for-5 · 5 PASmall sample
3Bryan Reynolds LF · S.261/.365/.789·17 HRvs hand.824 · 3-for-5 · 5 PA · Small69H-Score
4Brandon LoweL2B68.260.331.82435656.6120-for-2 · 2 PAVery small sample
4Brandon Lowe 2B · L.260/.331/.824·35 HRvs hand.612 · 0-for-2 · 2 PA · Very small68H-Score
5Nick GonzalesR3B48.303.367.7556608.653182 PA1-for-3 · 3 PAVery small sample
5Nick Gonzales 3B · R.303/.367/.755·6 HRvs hand.653 · 182 PA · 1-for-3 · 3 PA · Very small48H-Score
6Ronny SimonSRF—.254.299.648168.36412 PA · Small sampleNo MLB historyNo MLB history
6Ronny Simon RF · S.254/.299/.648·1 HRvs hand.364 · 12 PA · No MLB history · No MLB—H-Score
7Ryan O'HearnLRF59.265.330.77018451.630No MLB historyNo MLB history
7Ryan O'Hearn RF · L.265/.330/.770·18 HRvs hand.630 · No MLB history · No MLB59H-Score
8Jared TrioloRSS34.238.307.6093362.6880-for-3 · 3 PAVery small sample
8Jared Triolo SS · R.238/.307/.609·3 HRvs hand.688 · 0-for-3 · 3 PA · Very small34H-Score
9Jake MangumSCF38.276.331.6945479.675127 PA1-for-3 · 3 PAVery small sample
9Jake Mangum CF · S.276/.331/.694·5 HRvs hand.675 · 127 PA · 1-for-3 · 3 PA · Very small38H-Score